MPs Warn Security Minister UK Landline Switch-Off Could Cut Off Remote Areas in Emergencies

3.7 · 4d ago · WORLD · TECH

The Facts

  • UK landline operators aim to complete the switch from copper-wire to internet-based phone networks by the end of January next year. BBC only
  • MPs representing remote areas urged security minister Dan Jarvis to ensure the switch does not make communities more vulnerable in storms or other emergencies. BBC only
  • Unlike digital services, the traditional landline network does not rely on mains electricity and continues to work during a power cut. BBC only
  • BT Openreach has been giving back-up battery packs to vulnerable customers, which can keep landline phones working for an hour or more. BBC only
  • Labour MP Torcuil Crichton (Na h-Eileanan an Iar) said the batteries were 'simply not adequate' and that mobile providers lack the means to keep signals going during storms. BBC only
Dive deeper · 4 more factsShow less
  • Similar concerns were raised by MPs from the West Country and the Lake District, including Labour MP Markus Campbell-Savours (Penrith and Solway). BBC only
  • Conservative MP Julian Lewis raised the lack of a back-up system if digital phone services fail in a cyber attack or other emergency; Jarvis said he would 'look very closely' at the point. BBC only
  • Jarvis said West Country MPs' concerns would be addressed at a government resilience summit due in Cornwall next month, and promised to raise concerns about telecoms firms with the Department for Culture, Media and Sport. BBC only
  • The government says the digital switch is needed because the analogue network is becoming increasingly unreliable; providers must give vulnerable customers such as telecare users a free back-up battery unit. BBC only

Context

The UK's move from copper-wire landlines to internet-based phone services is due to finish by the end of January next year. MPs from remote constituencies told the security minister that digital lines depend on mains power and that mobile coverage can fail in storms.

The government and operators say digital landlines will be more reliable. Dan Jarvis, who leads the government's Be Ready campaign, said he would examine the concerns raised and take them up at a resilience summit and with the culture department.

How the Agent Panel Scored This

Independent AI personas each scored importance 1–10; the story's score is a trimmed mean (highest and lowest votes dropped). Vote spread: 1.

4 Informed Citizen The story reports MPs' concerns and a minister promising to look into them, with the underlying landline switch-off affecting many people but no new concrete action beyond a planned summit and inter-department referral, so impact is limited for now.
4 News Editor The story reports MPs' warnings and a minister promising to look into concerns, which is mostly rhetoric and future consideration, though the underlying nationwide landline switch-off has moderate real-world reach.
3 Business Analyst The story centers on MPs' concerns and a minister promising to look into them, with no new concrete regulatory action, though the underlying UK landline switch-off affects many households and is a notable infrastructure change.

Source

← All stories