Met Police Accepts Ex-Undercover Officer Andrew Coles Had Sexual Relationship With Activist
The Facts
- Andrew Coles, 66, served in the Metropolitan Police's Special Demonstration Squad (SDS) from 1990 to 1995, using the name Andy Davey taken from a dead child. BBC only
- Met commissioner Sir Mark Rowley wrote that the force accepts Coles had a sexual relationship with 'Jessica' (not her real name) and is disappointed he did not tell the truth to the Undercover Policing Inquiry. BBC only
- Coles denies the claims, saying he shared Jessica's bed once but there was never any sexual contact; he calls the allegation 'payback'. BBC only
- Jessica, now 54, says she met 'Davey' in 1991 aged 19, believed he was 24, but he was 32, married with children; she says he began a relationship with her. BBC only
- Evidence includes two handwritten 1993 letters from Jessica to a friend referring to the relationship; Coles suggests the second was written later, while Jessica shows other letters from the period in differing handwriting. BBC only
Dive deeper · 2 more factsShow less
- Coles says he took cannabis, squirted a bottle of alleged acid on a butcher's shop window, and took part in a chicken farm raid while undercover. BBC only
- Coles is also accused of appearing to advise colleagues to have similar relationships; he denies this. BBC only
Context
The Undercover Policing Inquiry has spent a decade examining the Met's SDS, which infiltrated protest groups; some officers deceived women activists into sexual relationships. Coles, brother of broadcaster Rev Richard Coles, was deployed to infiltrate the Animal Liberation Front.
The Met accepts a relationship occurred, while Coles disputes it. The BBC article is truncated; a forensic graphologist's assessment of Jessica's handwriting was cut off.
Conflicting Reports
- BBC: Jessica says Coles had sex with her; Coles says there was no sexual contact, though the Met accepts a sexual relationship occurred.
How the Agent Panel Scored This
Independent AI personas each scored importance 1–10; the story's score is a trimmed mean (highest and lowest votes dropped). Vote spread: 1.
| 4 | News Editor | This is a concrete development (the Met formally accepting a relationship occurred and the inquiry's findings) but it concerns a single former officer's past misconduct with limited immediate impact on a broad public, though it bears on the significant SDS scandal. |
| 3 | Informed Citizen | This story reports a Met acceptance of a past sexual relationship between a former undercover officer and an activist, plus a disputed denial, which is a notable inquiry development but with limited broad impact on ordinary people. |
| 3 | Business Analyst | The story reports a Met commissioner's written acknowledgment and a disputed personal allegation about a former undercover officer, which is a notable accountability matter but mostly statements and disputes with no new concrete policy, regulatory, or market-moving action. |