DOJ Charges 28 in California With Voting Crimes; LA County Calls 20,000-Name Noncitizen List Unreliable

5.4 · 11d ago · US

The Facts

  • The Justice Department has charged 28 people in California with voting crimes ahead of the midterm elections. ✓2 · NPR, Fox News
  • The DOJ filed a lawsuit on Oct. 15 seeking to force California to verify the citizenship of more than 20,000 registered voters the federal government believes are likely noncitizens, and to set aside mail ballots tied to them until citizenship is verified. USCIS produced the list by cross-checking voter records with federal immigration data; DOJ lawyers call the process preliminary. ✓2 · Fox News, NPR
  • Los Angeles County election officials said their preliminary analysis shows the DOJ list is unreliable. ✓2 · NPR, Fox News
  • The Justice Department announced Monday that Homeland Security agents in California arrested more than 20 people, all green card holders, on allegations of illegally registering or voting. CBS News only
  • In a court declaration, LA County official Monica Flores said that in a sample of 200 list records with LA County addresses, 112 were canceled or inactive registrations; of voters with a reported birthplace, 38.9% indicated they were born in the US; and 71.2% had no voting history. Fox News only
Dive deeper · 4 more factsShow less
  • Flores stated the registrar's office is not equipped or authorized to verify citizenship beyond voter attestation, and that setting aside ballots is now virtually impossible because verified ballots are separated from their envelopes; the county had processed 331,000 ballots as of Tuesday. Fox News only
  • Bill Essayli, first assistant U.S. attorney for the Central District of California, called Flores' statement a concession and said the reported numbers are meaningless. Newsom's office said California follows a 1993 federal law requiring DMV registrants to attest to citizenship under penalty of perjury. Fox News only
  • DHS Homeland Security Investigations agents, some armed, have been knocking on doors in several states since September to ask about immigration status and voter registration, as part of a surge initiative with field reviews in at least six states: California, Georgia, Missouri, Pennsylvania, Washington and Wisconsin. CBS News only
  • DOJ says 156 people have been charged with voting-fraud related offenses since the start of the Trump administration; DHS has alleged up to 250,000 noncitizens could be illegally registered, a figure election experts dispute. Protect Democracy is suing over the door-knocking campaign. CBS News only

Context

The Justice Department announced charges against 28 people in California for alleged voting crimes, about two weeks before Election Day. Separately, the DOJ is suing California over a list of more than 20,000 registered voters it deems likely noncitizens.

Los Angeles County officials say a sample of the list shows it is unreliable, with many records for inactive or canceled registrations and many people born in the US. DOJ officials dispute the significance of those findings. CBS News reports DHS agents have also been visiting homes in several states to ask about voter eligibility, which critics say may intimidate lawful voters.

Conflicting Reports

  • Fox News describes the 28 charged as foreign nationals; CBS News reports the California arrests (more than 20) were all green card holders.
  • DHS alleges up to 250,000 noncitizens may be registered; CBS News says election experts dispute that figure.

How the Agent Panel Scored This

Independent AI personas each scored importance 1–10; the story's score is a trimmed mean (highest and lowest votes dropped). Vote spread: 3.

7 Policy Expert The story reports concrete enforcement actions—federal charges against 28 people, arrests by DHS agents, and a lawsuit forcing citizenship verification of 20,000+ voters weeks before a midterm election—which significantly affect many voters and the state, though it is not sweeping nationwide breaking news.
6 News Editor The concrete events are 28 criminal charges and arrests of green card holders in California plus a federal lawsuit affecting over 20,000 voters ahead of midterms, which is newsworthy and politically significant but limited in direct impact on most residents.
6 Informed Citizen The story reports concrete actions (28 charges, over 20 arrests, a lawsuit seeking to set aside mail ballots, and a door-knocking surge in six states) ahead of midterms, which matters to California voters and election administration, though much of the coverage is disputes and rhetoric.
5 Global Affairs Analyst The story reports concrete actions (28 charges, over 20 arrests, a DOJ lawsuit seeking to set aside ballots for 20,000 voters, and a multi-state surge), which is newsworthy for election administration, but its scope is largely confined to California and the dispute is still mostly rhetorical and legal.
5 Science & Tech Analyst The story reports a concrete new action (28 federal voting-crime charges and arrests in California) and a DOJ lawsuit over 20,000 voters, which is newsworthy and consequential for an upcoming midterm, but its impact is regional and much of the content is disputed claims and rhetoric rather than a broad, immediate national shift.
5 Critical Reader The concrete events are 28 criminal charges and arrests of green card holders plus a federal lawsuit seeking to set aside ballots, which is a significant but regionally limited election-integrity action, with much of the story being disputed claims and rhetoric.
4 Business Analyst The concrete events are 28 criminal charges and arrests of green card holders plus a lawsuit over a 20,000-name list, which are notable regional election-law actions but have limited direct economic impact and mostly reflect rhetorical disputes between officials.

Sources (10)

← All stories